Skip to main content
  • Paterno's Pizza logo top - Homepage
    Paterno's Pizza logo scroll - Homepage
  • Menu
    • Food
    • Drinks
    • Specials
  • Catering
  • Parties
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Order
    • Doordash
    • Grubhub
    • Uber eats
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
Paterno's Pizza logo top - HomepagePaterno's Pizza logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Instagram page
  • Google page
  • Menu
    • Food
    • Drinks
    • Specials
  • Catering
  • Parties
  • Events
  • Jobs
  • Order
    • Doordash
    • Grubhub
    • Uber eats

Our Menu

  • Menu
  • Catering

*These items are cooked to order. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.

Appetizers

Mild or Hot Wings

8 pieces $9.99 | 12 pieces $13.49

Wisconsin Cheese Curds
$6.99
Homemade Mild Wings
$7.49/10 pieces

When available.

Cheese Balls
$6.99/15 pieces
Mozzarella Sticks
$6.99/6 pieces
Breaded Zucchini
$6.99
Breaded Mushrooms
$6.99
Onion Rings Beer Battered
$6.99
Breaded Cauliflower
$6.99
Jalapeno Poppers
$6.99/6 pieces

Cream cheese.

Sweet Potato Fries
$4.49
Combo Plate
$10.49

Assorted appetizers.

Fried Dough
$6.49

With marinara.

Calamari Fritti
$13.49/1/2 lb order
Nachos
$8.99

With Ground Beef +$3.00 | With Chicken +$4.00

Chips & Salsa
$7.49
Chips & Cheddar
$7.99
Tater Tots
$4.49
French Fries

Small $3.49 | Large $4.49

Cheese Fries
Additional Sauces

2 oz $0.50 | 4 oz $1.00

Salads

Dressings: Italian, French, 1000 Island, Garlic, Ranch, Caesar, Honey Mustard, Raspberry Vinaigrette, Poppyseed, Apple Vinaigrette, Sesame Ginger, Blue Cheese, Chipotle Ranch, Balsamic Vinaigrette

Salads Garden Salad
$7.99

Mix of iceberg & green leaf topped with carrots, cucumber, red onion, red cabbage & tomato.

Greek Salad
$9.49

Garden salad topped with feta, Kalamata olives, and anchovies.

Julienne Salad
$11.49

Garden salad topped with ham, turkey, American cheese, Swiss cheese, thinly sliced & a hard-boiled egg.

Antipasto Salad
$11.49

Garden salad topped with mortadella, Genoa salami & provolone cheese, thinly sliced, green olives & pepperrocinis.

Apple Chicken Salad
$11.99

Spring mix topped with carrots, red cabbage, grilled chicken breast, blue cheese crumbles, walnuts & cranberries served with apple vinaigrette on the side

Grilled Chicken
$11.49

Garden salad topped with our marinated grilled chicken breast.

Taco

Seasoned Ground Beef $9.99 | Grilled Chicken Breast $11.99
Bed of lettuce, sliced black olives, diced tomatoes, shredded cheddar & mozzarella, tortilla chips, sour cream & guacamole on the side with salsa dressing & choice of meat.

Asian Mandarin Chicken
$11.99

Bed of lettuce topped with mandarin oranges, sliced red peppers, Chow Mein noodles, sliced almonds & grilled chicken breast served with ginger sesame dressing on the side.

Tossed Chicken Caesar
$11.49

Lettuce mix, seasoned croutons, parmesan cheese & grilled chicken breast tossed with Caesar dressing.

Southwest Grilled Chicken
$12.49

Bed of lettuce, corn & black bean salsa, diced tomatoes, sliced black olives, tortilla chips, avocado & grilled chicken breast served with chipotle ranch dressing on the side.

Grilled Tuna Steak*
$13.99

Garden salad topped with grilled tuna steak* (please specify doneness of tuna steak).

Strawberry Spinach
$9.49

Seasonal | Bed of baby spinach, sliced strawberries, red onions & sliced almonds served with poppyseed dressing on the side.

Pear & Blue Cheese
$9.49

Seasonal | Spring mix topped with sliced pears, blue cheese crumble, walnuts & cranberries served with poppyseed dressing on the side.

Additional

Any Salad Chopped (extra) +$1.50
Additional Dressings (4 oz) +$1.00
Additional Anchovies +$2.50
Additional Chicken Breast +$4.00 each
Additional Egg +$1.50 each
Additional Tuna Steak* +$6.00 each

Soups

All soups or chili are served with crackers.

Soup Du Jour

8 oz $4.49 | 12 oz $5.49 | 16 oz $6.49 | 32 oz $11.99

Chili

8 oz $4.49 | 12 oz $5.49 | 16 oz $6.49 | 32 oz $11.99

Chili with Cheese

8 oz $4.99 | 12 oz $5.99 | 16 oz $6.99 | 32 oz $12.99

Chili Mac
$10.99

Chili on spaghetti or mostaccioli with garlic bread.

Baked Chili Mac
$12.99

Pasta

All pastas served with garlic bread.
Pastas served as dinner (with soup or salad) +$3.00

Marinara

Spaghetti, Mostaccioli, Linguine, Rigatoni, or Fettuccine $10.49
Cheese Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $11.99
Meat Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $12.49
Homemade Lasagna $12.49
Baked Mostaccioli $12.49

Meat Sauce

Spaghetti, Mostaccioli, Linguine, Rigatoni, or Fettuccine $10.99
Cheese Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $12.49
Meat Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $12.99
Homemade Lasagna $12.99
Baked Mostaccioli $12.99

Aglio & Olio

Spaghetti, Mostaccioli, Linguine, Rigatoni, or Fettuccine $10.99
Cheese Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $11.99
Meat Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $12.49
Linguine & Asparagus or Broccoli $13.49
Rigatoni Broccoli & Sausage $13.99
Rigatoni Broccoli & Chicken $15.49

White Clam Sauce

Spaghetti, Mostaccioli, Linguine, Rigatoni, or Fettuccine $11.99
Cheese Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $13.99
Meat Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $14.49

Red Clam Sauce

Spaghetti, Mostaccioli, Linguine, Rigatoni, or Fettuccine $12.49
Cheese Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $14.49
Meat Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $14.99

Alfredo Sauce

Spaghetti, Mostaccioli, Linguine, Rigatoni, or Fettuccine $12.49
Cheese Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $13.99
Meat Ravioli (8 jumbo filled) $14.49

Additions

2 Meatballs +$3.00
Sausage +$3.00
Chicken Breast +$4.00
Shrimp +$5.00

Incredibles Sandwiches

Served on garlic bread with melted cheese.

Beef
$8.99
Meatball
$8.49
Sausage
$8.49
Eggplant Parmesan
$8.49
Pepper & Egg*
$7.49
Combo
$10.99

Choice of two meats | Chicken not included.

Chicken
$10.99
Sub
$7.99

Burgers

All burgers are 1/3 pound*

Hamburger
$6.49
Cheeseburger
$6.99
Pizza Burger
$7.49
Mushroom Burger
$7.49
Patty Melt
$7.99
Bacon & Bleu Cheese Burger
$9.99
Southwest Burger
$9.49
Turkey Burger
$7.49
Additional

Double Patty +$3.00
Bacon +$3.00
Extra Cheese +$1.00

Sandwiches

All cold sandwiches served with dressing, lettuce, tomato & onion.

Philly Cheese Steak
$9.99
Steak Italiano
$10.49
Chicken Philly
$11.49
Grilled Veggie
$7.99
BLT
$7.99
Turkey Club
$7.99
BBQ Beef
$8.49
Italian Beef
$7.99
Cold Beef
$8.49

With cheese.

Combo - Beef & Sausage
$10.49
Italian Sausage
$7.49
Meatball
$7.49
Italian Sub
$6.99
Hot Dog
$3.49
Cheese Dog
$3.99
Chili Dog
$3.99
Chili Cheese Dog
$4.49
Chicken Breast
$7.99

Fried or grilled.

Ham & Cheese
$6.99
Turkey
$6.99
Turkey Melt
$7.99
Tuna
$6.99
Tuna Melt
$7.99
Fish
$6.49
1/2 # Corned Beef
$10.99
Corn Beef
$8.99
1/2 # Reuben
$12.49
Reuben
$10.49
Salami Provolone
$7.99
American Sub
$6.99
Chicken Parmesan
$10.99

With marinara.

Veal Parmesan
$10.99
Pepper & Egg*
$6.49
Grilled Cheese
$5.99
Additional

Most Sandwich served with soup or salad +$3.00
Deluxe Sandwich served with fries & cole slaw +$3.00
Meat Sauce or Marinara on a Sandwich +$0.75
Cheese on Sandwich +$1.00

Tacos

Beef or Pork Taco
$3.49
Chicken Taco
$3.69
Shrimp Taco
$3.99
Fish Taco
$3.49

Specials

Hot Dog Special
$7.99

2 dogs & fries.

Pizza Thin Crust

10" serves 1 | 12" serves 1-2 | 14" serves 2-3 | 16" serves 3-4 | 18" serves 4-5

Extra-thin crust available upon request.

Cheese

10" $9.99 | 12" $13.99 | 14" $15.99 | 16" $18.99 | 18" $22.99
Pizza sauce base and cheese.

Butter

10" $9.99 | 12" $13.99 | 14" $15.99 | 16" $18.99 | 18" $22.99
Garlic butter base & cheese no pizza sauce!

Additional

Toppings: 10" $1.75 | 12" $2.25 | 14" $3.00 | 16" $3.50 | 18" $4.00
Premium Toppings: 10" $3.75 | 12" $4.25 | 14" $5.00 | 16" $5.50 | 18" $6.00
Double Crust: 10" $2.00 | 12" $3.00 | 14" $4.00 | 16" $5.00 | 18" $6.00

Meat Toppings:

House Made Sausage | House Made Meatball | House Made Italian Beef | Imported Ham | Pepperoni | Genoa Salami | Ground Beef

Vegetable Toppings:

Sliced Tomato | Fresh Mushroom | Giardinera | Green Olives | Black Olives | Fresh Broccoli | Green Peppers | Jalapeno | Fresh Spinach | Onion | Red Onion | Pineapple | Fresh Garlic | Pepperocinis | Fresh Basil

Premium Toppings:

Chicken | Shrimp | Bacon | Anchovy | Ricotta | Blue Cheese | Roasted Red Pepper

Speciality Pizzas

10" $16.99 | 12" $19.99 | 14" $22.99 | 16" $26.99 | 18" $31.99

Extra-thin crust available upon request.

Paterno Special

Sausage, mushroom, onion & green peppers.

Vegetarian Special

Mushroom, onion, green peppers & sliced tomato.

Philly Cheese Steak

Philly steak with sauteed mushroom, onion & green peppers.

Taco

Salsa base topped with ground beef, refried beans, mozzarella & cheddar cheeses.

Buffalo Chicken

Hot sauce base chicken & blue cheese crumbles.

BBQ

BBQ sauce base, pepperoni, sausage & bacon.

BBQ Chicken

BBQ sauce base, chicken, red onions & cilantro.

Florida Special

Super thin crust, olive oil base, fresh garlic, pepperoni, fresh sliced tomato, topped with mozzarella.

Meat Lovers

Sausage, pepperoni & bacon.

Pizza Slices

Jumbo pizza slice.

Cheese
$3.49
Sausage
$3.99
Fresh Tomato & Spinach
$4.49
Sausage & Roasted Red Pepper
$4.49
Veggie
$5.49
Pepperoni
$3.99
Mushroom
$3.99
Paterno Special Slice
$5.49

Sausage, mushroom, onion & green pepper.

Meat Lovers
$5.49

Sausage, pepperoni & bacon.

Additional

Ingredients on Slices +$0.75
Shrimp, Chicken, or Bacon +$2.50
Anchovies +$1.25

Dinners

Chicken Parmesan
$12.49

Served on your choice of pasta with (with marinara and garlic bread).

Eggplant Parmesan
$12.99

Served with your choice of pasta.

Eggplant Parmesan
$10.99
Shrimp
$13.49

Served with fries & cole slaw.

Shrimp & Fish Combo
$13.99

Served with fries & cole slaw.

Fish & Chips
$11.99
Chicken Tenders
$7.99

With sauce.

Additional

Add a Soup or Salad -$3.00
Make it a Deluxe with Fries and Cole Slaw +$3.00

Sides

Pizza Bread
$5.49

Additional Toppings +$0.75
Add Bacon, Chicken, or Shrimp +$2.50

Garlic Bread

Anchovies $1.25 | One Slice $1.49 | Two Slices $2.99 | Loaf $6.99

Garlic Bread with Cheese

One Slice $1.99 | Two Slices $3.99 | Loaf $7.99

French Roll
$0.99

With butter +$1.99

Loaf of Bread
$3.49

With butter $6.49

Sausage or Meatballs
$5.49
Meatballs
$6.99

With garlic bread.

French Fries

Small $3.49 | Large $4.49

Cheese Fries
$5.49
Gravy Bread
$2.99
Whole Pickle
$2.99
Hard Boiled Egg
$1.50/each
Sweet Peppers
$0.75
Hot Gardinera
$0.75
Jalapeno
$0.75
Sport Pepper
$0.75
Pepperoncini
$0.75

Desserts

Cannoli
$3.99

Fresh filled.

Cheese Cake
$4.99
Fried Dough
$5.99

With powdered sugar.

Prices subject to change without notice.

Appetizers

Wings Hot or Mild

25 pieces $39.99 | 50 pieces $69.99 | 100 pieces $125.99
Served with blue cheese or ranch & hot sauce.

Fried Shrimp
$59.99/50 pieces

Served with cocktail sauce & lemon.

Chicken Tenders

1/2 pan $29.99 | Full Pan $59.99
With a choice of sauce.

Salads

Garden

1/2 Pan $39.99 | Full Pan $44.95

Antipasto

1/2 Pan $49.95 | Full Pan $89.95

Julienne

1/2 Pan $49.95 | Full Pan $89.95

Grilled Chicken

1/2 Pan $44.95 | Full Pan $79.99

Tossed Grilled Chicken Caesar

1/2 Pan $44.95 | Full Pan $79.99

Apple Chicken Salad

1/2 Pan $49.95 | Full Pan $89.99

Pear & Blue Cheese

1/2 Pan $39.99 | Full Pan $69.99

Strawberry Spinach

1/2 Pan $29.99 | Full Pan $55.99

Sandwich Trays

All made with lettuce, tomato, onion & dressing.
Available in 2" or 3" cuts.

Italian

Small $34.95 | Medium $59.99 | Large $89.99

American

Small $34.95 | Medium $59.99 | Large $89.99

Tuna

Small $34.95 | Medium $59.99 | Large $89.99

Turkey

Small $34.95 | Medium $59.99 | Large $89.99

Ham & Cheese

Small $34.95 | Medium $59.99 | Large $89.99

Cold Roast Beef & Cheese

Small $36.99 | Medium $69.99 | Large $99.99

House Specialites

Chicken Parmesan, Chicken Marsala or Chicken Piccata -Boneless Breasts

8 pieces $39.99 | 16 pieces $75.99

Italian Roasted, Breaded, Vesuvio or Bbq Chicken- Bone-N Mixed Parts

25 pieces $59.99 | 50 pieces $119.99

Sausage & Peppers 4” Cuts

20 pieces $39.99 | 40 pieces $75.95

Meatballs in Marinara
$24.00/12 pieces
Baked Mostaccioli, Lasagna or Eggplant Parmesan With Marinara

1/2 Pan $44.99 | Full Pan $84.99

Baked Mostaccioli or Lasagna with Meat Sauce

1/2 Pan $49.99 | Full Pan $94.99

Baked Mostaccioli, Lasagna with Spinach

1/2 Pan $49.99 | Full Pan $94.99

Stuffed Shells with Ricotta & Spinach and Marinara

18 pieces $39.99 | 36 pieces $74.99

Stuffed Shells with Ricotta, Fresh Spinach, Ground Beef or Sausage & Marinara

18 pieces $44.95 | 36 pieces $84.99

Cheese Ravioli with Marianra

40 pieces $54.95 | 80 pieces $104.95

Meat Ravioli with Marinara

40 pieces $55.95 | 80 pieces $104.95

Pastas

Mostaccioli, Linguine, Spaghetti, Rigatoni, or Fettuccine.

Marinara

1/2 Pan $39.95 | Full Pan $74.95

Meat Sauce

1/2 Pan $44.95 | Full Pan $84.95

Aglio & Olio

1/2 Pan $34.95 | Full Pan $64.95

White Clam Sauce

1/2 Pan $44.95 | Full Pan $84.95

Red Clam Sauce

1/2 Pan $49.95 | Full Pan $94.95

Alfredo Sauce

1/2 Pan $44.95 | Full Pan $84.95

Rigatoni, Broccoli & Sausage

1/2 Pan $54.95 | Full Pan $104.95

Rigatoni, Broccoli & Chicken

1/2 Pan $64.95 | Full Pan $124.95

Sides

Meatball in Marinara
$2.00/each
Meatballs No Sauce
$1.50/each
Potatoes, Butter Baked, Vesuvio, or Parsley Boiled

1/2 Pan $34.95 | Full Pan $64.95

Fresh String Beans, Baby Carrots, or Broccoli

1/2 Pan $34.95 | Full Pan $64.95

Fresh Homemade Bread Baked Daily-Loaf
$3.49
Garlic Bread Made on Our Homemade Bread-Loaf
$6.99
Garlic Bread with Cheese-Loaf
$7.99
Paterno's Homemade Roast Beef with Gravy
$10.99
Paterno's Homemade Sausage
$5.99
Sweet Peppers
$5.49
Pasta Salad
$5.99
Pasta Salad with Salami & Provolone Cheese
$7.99
Homemade Cole Slaw
$3.99
Marinara by The Quart
$9.99
Meat Sauce by The Quart
$11.99
4" French Roll
$6.49/8 pk
6" French Roll
$6.49/6 pk

Packages

Package #1
$84.95

5# Homemade Italian Beef with Gravy
24-4” Rolls
1# Sweet Peppers
1 Pint Hot Giardiniera

Packages #2
$99.95

5# Homemade Italian Beef with Gravy
5# Cole Slaw
24-4” Rolls
1# Sweet Peppers
1 Pint Hot Giardiniera

Packages #3
$129.95

5# Homemade Italian Beef with Gravy
5# Homemade Italian Sausage
40 -4” French Rolls
2# Sweet Peppers
1 Pint Hot Giardinera

Package #4
$155.95

5# Homemade Italian Beef with Gravy
Full Pan Baked Mostaccioli with Marinara (meat Sauce +$10.00)
24-4” French Rolls
1 # Sweet Peppers
1 Pint Giardiniera

Package #5
$184.95

5#homemade Roast Beef with Gravy
5# Homemade Italian Sausage
25 Pc Chicken Choice Bredaed, Vesuvio, or Italian Roasted
48 Pc -4” French Rolls
2# Sweet Pepper
1 Pint Hot Giardiniera

Package # 6
$249.95

5# Homemade Roast Beef with Gravy
5# Homemade Italian Sausage
25 Pc Chicken Choice of Breaded, Vesuvio, or Italian Roasted
Full Pan Baked Mostaccioli with Marinara (meat Sauce +$10.00)
48 Pc-4” French Rolls
2# Sweet Peppers
1 Pint Hot Giardinera

Location

5303 N Milwaukee Ave
Chicago, IL
60630

Find us on

Facebook pageInstagram pageGoogle page

Hours

Sun, Wed, Thur, Fri, Sat:
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

Contact us

Call us at (773)-631-5522

Write us at paternospizza@gmail.com

  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs